Rules:
- Iron and Fire by David Manley
- 1:1200 ships by Pithead Miniatures/Spithead Miniatures
- 2mm guns by Irregular Miniatures
- Beige Vynl fabric for river
- Green fleece
- Woodland Scenics Bushes Clump-Foliage, Medium Green, 32oz
Photo 1: Initial deployment. Paraguayans anchored at bottom. Brazilian ships in line moving towards Paraguayans. Two more Brazilians ships to enter.
Photo 2: Brazilian ships in line. Note line showing extent of shallows on starboard of ships.
Photo 3: Paraguayan field battery provides support from shore.
Photo 4: Paraguayans decide to raise anchor and move towards Brazilians.
Photo 5: Ships from both sides are now getting in close.
Photo 6: River is filled with smoke from the battle. The Paraguayan flagship has rammed a Brazilian ship and captured the ship as their own ship sinks.
Photo 7: Last photo showing the second last turn in the game. Not much changed in the last turn.
I called the game after four hours of game play. Unfortunately the Paraguayans could not change the historical outcome. The results were identical to history. All Chatas (towed boats) and four ships on the Paraguayan side were sunk. One Brazilian ship was sunk, but the Paraguayan Admiral was captured. I did not tell either side what the victory conditions were. The Paraguayans would have won if they did better than historically (lose less ships and/or sink more ships).
I recommend this scenario. It is a good unknown or barely known battle. The models are great and the rules went very smoothly, although I did forget about the possible effect of rolling a one on gunfire. If I run the game again, I will start the battle further up river where the two sides first met. Maybe we could see how the Paraguayans would do by not heading downstream and anchoring.
Rules wise, the rule about being easier to hit if stationary, maybe this rule could be dropped because the Paraguayans are at a disadvantage anchored.
A future post, I will share resources for you to use for building this scenario or just for reading.
Other posts on Battle of Riachuelo:
Nice looking game!
ReplyDeleteSimply how I imagined this battle to be look on a wargame table, top marks. Have you ever tried to use plan "A" and take out some of the Brazilian ships as their crews slept ashore during the night then fight the battle on more even terms.
ReplyDeleteI plan to run the same scenario again someday but earlier in the morning, when things should be more even. I probably also need to look into a what-if scenario.
DeleteI look forward to reading the account. The issue of stationary targets is interesting, the range changes when firing on a moving target so its more difficult to acquire but on the other hand the gun platform of a stationary vessel is steadier which should improve accuracy. I would certainly give the shore guns some sort of bonus though. There way in which each Brazilian commanders interpreted their order was interesting, some were overly aggressive to the point of being out of control where others seemed to hold back after coming under fire from long range field artillery. Perhaps each ships commander (apart from the flagship) should be given a personality card on how they would react under certain conditions. I don't think that it would alter the outcome but it would make the game interesting and less predictable.
Delete